TheColdCases.com Podcast | True Crime & Cold Cases
TheColdCases.com Podcast | True Crime & Cold Cases was founded by Dustin Terry, who also serves as its host. The show takes listeners on a deep dive into the chilling world of true crime and cold cases that have left communities searching for answers. Each episode uncovers mysteries ranging from haunting murder stories to puzzling disappearances, exploring the evidence and unraveling the threads of cases that have long remained unsolved.
Through careful investigative journalism, the podcast delivers gripping stories that reveal the dark realities behind real crimes.
Whether you are fascinated by shocking crimes, drawn to thoughtful reporting, or interested in the pursuit of justice, the podcast explores the facts, the theories, and the people behind each case.
Listeners are invited to join as TheColdCases.com Podcast shines a light on the unknown, revisits forgotten stories, and searches for the truth behind the headlines. From decades-old mysteries to ongoing investigations, it serves as a powerful guide through the world of crime, unsolved cases, and the relentless search for answers.
Links
Website: https://www.thecoldcases.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100080656281952
Email: dustinreedterry@gmail.com
Episodes
27 episodes
John Hartenfeld’s Cold Case and His Son’s Long Search for Truth
In August 1996, John Hartenfeld drove into the mountains of northern New Mexico for a solo fly fishing trip and never came home. His Toyota 4-Runner was found two months later on remote ranch land — every fingerprint wiped from the vehicle. His...
15 Year Old Shaylee Snyder Was Lured & Murdered
#JusticeForShaylee: She Was Not a RunawayFifteen-year-old Shaylee Snyder disappeared from Indianapolis on February 10, 2025. Her family went to police with burner phones, medical records, and eyewitness accounts — and were told, <...
Grandpa Guy Monroe Pyke Just Simple Disappeared. Why?
In April 1999, 70-year-old Guy Pyke pulled into his cousin's driveway in Evans Mills, New York — and never got out of the car. A barking dog kept him away. He backed out, drove north, and was never seen again.No body. No crash sit...
People Know Gary Butler's Killer But Won't Say
On the morning of February 26, 1996, 25-year-old Gary Butler was found dead in a retention pond in Manville, New Jersey. Police initially called it a hit-and-run. The evidence said otherwise. Nearly thirty years later, no one has been charged —...
Who Killed Devan Sanders? A Community's Loss
Devan Sanders came home from work around 11 p.m. on a stormy August night in 2018. Something — or someone — drew him back outside into the rain. He was found shot to death on the side of his own house hours later, steps from his front door in D...
Who Killed Patricia Shea? An Investigation
On the night of July 25, 1982, Patricia "Pat" Shea — a beloved physician's assistant from Rockaway Beach, Queens — crossed the street to check on an elderly neighbor. She was found strangled eleven miles away in Brooklyn's Prospect Park the nex...
Croft and Barrow Jane Does Family Speaks About Identification
In November 2008, an electric company crew replacing a power pole in Oklahoma City made a grim discovery — the partial remains of a young woman. She was Native American, estimated to be between 17 and 23 years old, and she had no name. The only...
Someone Close to Elizibeth Green Knows Something and They're Not Telling
In April 2024, 21-year-old Elizibeth "Lizzy" Green walked out the front door of her home in Callao, Utah — a remote desert community of fewer than 50 people — and was never seen again. Nearly two years later, no physical evidence has been found...
Was Jack Morgan Killed by his Dad for Being Gay?
In December 1996, fifteen-year-old Jack Morgan vanished from his San Diego home after an argument with his father. No clothes taken. No money. No note. Nothing.Authorities called it a runaway case. His father called it closed — throwing ...
Maryah Hope Allen Walked Out of Jail and Vanished
Episode Description:In April 2018, 17-year-old Maryah Hope Allen walked out of a Galveston County jail cell in Texas — and vanished. Today, her grandmother Phyllis Jones, the woman who raised her, is breaking her silence. She tell...
Jimmie Retha Brown and a Suspect Who "Allegedly" Got Away With Murder
In the summer of 1977, sixteen-year-old Jimmie Retha Brown got into a van with a man her friend said she could trust. She was never seen alive again.Found bound and strangled in the New Mexico desert days later, Jimmie's murder set off a...
Douglas "DJ" Shondel II Is a Case That Should've Been Easily Solved
It has been more than two decades since Douglas James Shondel II — known to those who loved him as “DJ” — died under circumstances that his family, and even first responders, found deeply troubling. He was 21 years old. His mother, Pam Scott, h...
Who Killed Claude Wendell Johnson?
Who Killed Claude Wendell Johnson?More than four decades have passed, but Tammie Johnson still doesn't have answers — and she's not giving up.In this deeply personal episode, we sit down with Tammie Johnson, the daughter of...
Deanna Merryfield Updates | Unsolved
In July 1990, 13-year-old Deanna Merryfield disappeared from Killeen, Texas under circumstances that remain deeply troubling more than three decades later.In this episode of The Cold Cases Podcast, I sit down with Meli...
Pacific Atrocities Education Discusses WWII War Crimes in Asia
In this powerful episode, we sit down with Jenny Chan, founder of Pacific Atrocities Education ( https://www.pacificatrocities.org ), to explore the hidden history of Imperial Japan's systematic atrocities during World War II—a chapter largely ...
Tulsa Race Riots & Rev. Stephenson’s Film
In this powerful and deeply reflective episode, I sit down with Kevin Stephenson, Reverend and President of Faith Based Films LLC, to discuss his upcoming film project, 1921, which explores the Tulsa Race Riots of 1921—one ...
Little Miss Panasoffkee Maureen Rowan’s Daughter Speaks Out in Exclusive Interview
In this powerful episode of The Cold Cases Podcast, we sit down with Ann Patrick — the daughter of Maureen “Cookie” Rowan, recently identified as the woman long known only as “Little Miss Lake Panasoffkee.” After more than fifty years without a...
Family of Arash Nikoonejad Seek Justice for 2019 Gainesville Murder
In this powerful episode of The Cold Cases Podcast, host Dustin Terry sits down with Zahra Abyazenjad, the mother of Arash Nikoonejad, a 27-year-old Gainesville man whose life was tragically cut short in November 2...
David Charles Matte & Lingering Questions in Lafayette | Unsolved
In this emotional and revealing episode of TheColdCases.com Podcast, host Dustin Terry sits down with Lori Matte, the sister of 45-year-old David Charles Matte, who was brutally attacked and left for dead on the si...
Kevin Laws & Hunter of the Damned | True Crime
In this gripping episode of The Cold Cases, host Dustin Terry sits down with Kevin J. Laws, former Department of Homeland Security child-exploitation agent and author of the haunting memoir Hunter of the Damned: ...
Maeve McGoran & Shipwreck - A Fascinating Interview | True Crime
In this powerful episode of The Cold Cases, host Dustin Terry sits down with Maeve McGoran, creator of the gripping true-crime podcast ShipWreck, to explore the depths of human tragedy, resilience, and justice. M...
Robin Abrams Family Speaks Out on Power, Secrecy, Corruption | True Crime
In this episode of TheColdCases.com Podcast, I sit down with Jody Walsh, sister of missing Will County Sheriff’s Deputy Robin Abrams, who vanished in 1990 under circumstances that still raise hard questions. Jody shares w...
Lidia Jean Kott & Chinatown Sting | True Crime
Journalist and podcast host Lidia Jean Kott joins TheColdCases.com Podcast to take us inside The Chinatown Sting—an investigative series that follows an undercover operation, a web of heroin shipments hidden in everyday objects,...